Caught a Sunday matinee of this, mostly out of curiosity. Ended up enjoying it. Going in with no expectations helps, but it’s just your basic light-hearted romantic comedy with a slight twist concerning fan obsession.
Ah, but you are perhaps wondering what I think of this version compared to the first theatrical version starring Colin Firth? Probably not, since most people don’t realize Nick Hornby’s book was made into a movie prior to this one, but I’ll give you my thoughts anyway: I liked the first one better.
This is not a “”typical”" reason. The reason is more that Jimmy Fallon’s character, as Sun pointed out as we left the theater, is actually quite likable and would easily have found someone were it not for being a bit crazy about the Red Sox. Thing is, sure, that’s fine, but Colin Firth’s character? That one was a bit darker, more bitter, more emotionally-charged in high hopes and low expectations. Further, while Fallon sports boyish charm, Firth appears to be simply a boy, with the charm and the innocence that are seen in an adult as being tactless and self-centered. It’s a much more compelling character to watch.
So yes, fun movie, but I don’t plan to buy this one when it comes out on DVD, satisfied that my Nick Hornby movie adaptations collection already has a Fever Pitch I’d watch over and over again.
link
April 27th, 2005 at 10:52 am
remember PINE? those were the days.
sincerely,
the former izzytn8@ucla.edu